1999 Holden Acclaim review from Australia and New Zealand
"For those who value quantity over quality"
What things have gone wrong with the car?
The transmission goes 'clunk' all the time and the car rolls backwards. Selecting reverse makes it sound like the transmission has fallen out. Fixed under warranty once, but still is horrible to use.
Driver's side door rattles and vibrates badly.
Airbag warning light goes on and off as it pleases. Dealer doesn't think there's a problem.
Fuel warning comes on when there's half a tank, but fails to work when nearly empty.
Rubber seal around fuel filler has fallen off.
Engine management computer gave up at 15,000 km. Fixed under warranty.
Occasionally develops a mysterious intermittent hesitation/misfire when under load, but leads, plugs, fine.
Power steering shudders at low speeds and makes a knocking sound (just started to happen)
General comments?
For such a big car it feel like you're in the Bat Cave. Roof too low in the front.
V6 has bags of grunt down low, but coarse and unrewarding when revved.
Auto trans can't decide what gear it wants most of the time and thumps and bangs like a two year-old with an attitude problem.
Is surprisingly light on fuel if driven gently.
Build quality questionable.
Seats very uncomfortable on long trips.
All Commodores I have been in have a similar smell that I am beginning to dislike. (Except Commodore taxis - they smell like a mixture of vinyl, sweat and vomit)
Recommended reviews
![]() ![]() | I'd rather push my Holden than drive your Ford |
![]() ![]() | Well rounded performance, economy, comfort and safety |
| Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? | No |
| First year of ownership | 1999 |
| Most recent year of ownership | 2002 |
| Engine and transmission | 3.8 V6 Automatic |
| Performance marks | 7/10 |
| Reliability marks | 4/10 |
| Comfort marks | 7/10 |
| Dealer Service marks | 4/10 |
| Running Costs (higher is cheaper) | 6/10 |
| Distance when acquired | 27 kilometres |
| Most recent distance | 68000 kilometres |
| Previous car | Toyota Corolla |
| Date of Entry | 10th October, 2003 |

