1999 Mercury Cougar review from North America
"You get what you paid for, though not as bad as a Cavalier, Sunfire or Neon!!!"
What things have gone wrong with the car?
I bought the car in Sept. of 1999 supposedly brand new right before the dealership got their 2000 models in with 636 miles on it. At about 3000 miles, the catalytic converter had to be replaced (it smelled like rotten eggs). The instrument cluster had to be replaced due to moisture, my stereo/single CD unit had to be replaced due to the removable preset buttons not working. The left rear speaker had to be replaced. The piece that covers the defrost popped up and won't stay clipped in. This is all when it was still under Ford's warranty. Just after the warranty ran out, my alternator stopped working. I purchased a remanufactered one from Advanced Auto, called Ford service department and asked if there was any special tools needed to complete the job and what parts needed to be removed. No special tools needed and said we needed to remove passenger front tire and maybe something else. I had an experienced friend try to replace and tried for 3 hours using different tools and extensions to even get a socket or wrench and a bolt and could not. Come to find out, the alternator on the car was a Ford reman. I called my dealer and they said it was replaced at 200+ miles. And this was supposed to be a NEW car when I bought it. Even though not under warranty, they agreed to pay everything except for towing and the first $50 of total cost ($90.00 total out of my pocket). I'm not sure what it cost, but when I was calling around for price quotes for a reman. alternator, they quoted me over $400 just for the part. I feel I could have gotten more from them now, but was so desperate to get my car running again, I would have taken any help at the time. Since then my window washer does not work, my fog lights don't work, they went out at the same time so I don't think it is the bulbs, and now my check engine light is on. I have always done the proper maintenance, oil change every 3,000 to 5,000 miles like Ford recommends, etc. Please leave a comment if any of this has happened to your Cougar, because it will give me a better insight and I won't feel like mine is the only one. Thanks.
General comments?
Overall, this is a fun car. September 2004 will be 5yrs that I have had the car. I have done some modifications like a 2 inch drop using Eibach lowering springs and a Ractive intake with a K&N filter. Intake made a big difference in acceleration and the springs makes it handle so well around tight turns, but make ride much more rough. I will be trading it in for another make and model before they won't give me anything for a trade in. The value of these Cougars are horrible!!
Recommended reviews
![]() ![]() | Piece of junk |
![]() ![]() | 1999 - Cougar California Specia Edition 2.5LV6 More problems than one can handle |
| Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? | Yes |
| First year of ownership | 1999 |
| Most recent year of ownership | 2004 |
| Engine and transmission | V6 Automatic |
| Performance marks | 8/10 |
| Reliability marks | 7/10 |
| Comfort marks | 6/10 |
| Dealer Service marks | 8/10 |
| Running Costs (higher is cheaper) | 5/10 |
| Distance when acquired | 636 miles |
| Most recent distance | 79500 miles |
| Previous car | Ford Ranger |
| Date of Entry | 14th July, 2004 |

