2007 BMW Mini Cooper S from UK and Ireland - Comments

This is my second Mini Cooper S after BMW replaced my existing Mini with a brand new Mini, due to the numerous faults I had.

I have now owned my new Mini for approx 3 months; it has approx 1,500 miles and already there are faults.

Girstly the car has returned to have the windscreen ducting installed, as it was not fitted from the factory; this was causing a very awful squeaking noise as the dash was butting up to the windscreen.

Secondly, I now have the same problem as I did on my old Mini; I have contacted mini who confirm this is a feature or more like a fault in my opinion. From time to time upon starting the car, it makes a terrible diesel type noise. Mini have informed me this noise is due to the tappets not filling with oil, hence the noise. It sounds awful.

Thirdly, I have a rattle coming from the left side, possible the suspension; this fault was also reported on my old mini. Mini were unable to rectify this fault on my old Mini.

Please, please, please, is there anybody out there with the same faults.? I am so disappointed with my car, you pay all this money, expecting quality, but instead I am very dissatisfied!!!

The Mini S looks great from all angles, the performance is also impressive for a 1.6. The car handles and drives very well indeed.

My mini 2007 MCS at 11k has had a few minor annoyances, but nothing that has warranted visiting the dealer. I have experienced none of the issues that you have mentined. Strongly suggest that you go on the Nam Mini site at http://www.northamericanmotoring.com/ and check out problem forums than get with the dealer and they will correct. Motor on. My own review is posted on the carsurvey sight six months or more ago and have have had no reason to change a word on it.

I have a new Cooper, and so far so good. Squeaking suspension can be annoying and disappointing on a new car, but the dealer really should sort this out. But this depends on the dealer! Noisy valve train from cold is quite normal, and can be made worse when the weather is cold. Unless you leave the engine idling, it should go as soon as the engine RPM is increased. But usually it should only be noisy when cold starting and not every time with a warm engine.

The only poor quality I have found on my MINI are that knobs for both the mirrors and the stereo volume, feel and look cheap. I am expecting them to fall off anytime. And the small covering hatches for the brake fluid and battery are terrible. The entire plastic cover in front of the windscreen and the hatches are moulded in one. The hinge is just the plastic. First time I opened the one on the right hand side (just to see what was there) it broke off! No excuse from BMW for this sort of stuff.

New nmini cooper s 2008 model. very poor quality plastics on my car. plastics on wheel arches etc went from black to light grey in just a few days from new. dealer says there is a chemical in the new plastics to keep them black and they should not be cleaned with anything. Any suggestions?

I worked in a mini parts warehouse. We sold a lot of replacement parts. The parts BMW uses on Mini's are not very good quality. I stick with my common Honda Civic.