2007 Renault Scenic 2.0 LPG

Summary:

Practical, fun to drive, noisy at speed

Faults:

Nothing. However, I bought it with a faulty temperature sensor of the LPG installation. That's probably why the dealer sold it cheap to me. It wouldn't switch from gasoline to LPG easily, sometimes not at all. I had the thermostat changed, it wasn't it and then I had the temperature sensor changed (the part cost me 24 eur) and the installation started working perfectly. The car felt like new after 200 000 km, apart from some scratches. I'm impressed.

General Comments:

Very practical, reasonably comfortable, fun to drive, noisy after 3000 rpm.

I was not looking for a Renault, but this one had an LPG installation, and here in Germany the installation was more expensive than the car itself. And the car was cheap and good looking. Also, the three separate back seats were a good feature for my GF's kids.

Really nothing went wrong with the car. I drove 20 000 km in 6 months with it and it was very reliable.

The parts are reasonably cheap (Why does engine oil cost so much in Germany???). It is not very easy to work under the hood - everything is tightly crammed but I guess this is true for all new cars. It is not extremely difficult to work under the hood either. And perhaps it saves a few centimeters of the car's length. Ah, one negative side: you do have to remove the battery to change the front left light bulb. Luckily, I had to change the right bulb which wasn't easy either. I had absolutely no way to look inside the housing of the headlight so I had to feel how the bulb was attached. Really, no way. (Except perhaps if I had some elaborate mirror system). At least it was doable.

Perhaps I had luck with a well maintained car, but mechanically it did feel like new (I work as a driver and I usually drive new cars).

The interior is very practical, there are drawers under the front seats and under the two side seats in the rear. There's a huge console under the armrest where you can store many things. So, storage room is more than enough. On the negative side - the glovebox is not too large (but it is ok) and there are no cupholders. (You can buy aftermarket solutions for 5 bucks on ebay but they are not really convenient).

The seats are comfortable, even for long trips. They are not as comfortable as Mercedes seats, but they are still comfortable enough. In a Mercedes you get in with a back pain and you get out without it. In the Scenic you get in without back pain and you get out without back pain. (I sold my previous car mainly because I couldn't get used to the seats).

The driver's position is good and adjustable, the steering wheel is also adjustable for length and height, which makes the driving position really comfortable (although I wish it would have had more adjustable length). Legroom is ok in the front and I think OK in the rear. (I was always the driver but it felt OK whenever I would get in the back seat for whatever reason. The back seats could also be moved back and forth.

My car had a sunroof which I quite liked and which functioned without any problems.

The interior feels plasticky but not in a bothersome way. I mean, you are driving a small Renault, what were you expecting? Therefore you have a reasonable and cheap to maintain car.

The size of the car is perfect - it is short enough so you can easily find a parking spot even when it's tight. Yet, it is comfy for the passengers, the boot is tall, the rear seats fold down (the front passenger seat too) and you can transport all kinds of large boxy objects like a washing machine.

Now to the important part:

The handling is very good. The car feels very agile. I have never had to consider body roll with it and I do make sharp turns. The two liter engine gets you quickly off the mark and accelerates well. It had 6 manual gears. The gear stick is on the dash but it felt comfortable to reach and handle there. It also felt soft after so many kms which I liked. However, 6th gear is quite short. Only 38.5 km/h or so for 1000 revolutions. This means, the higher the speed, the higher the revolutions. The engine gets really really noisy after 3000 rpm (and my exhaust system was not damaged). I had the feeling the engine was gonna crawl into the passenger space as soon as I reached 3000 rpm. This means, the car is OK to drive up to 120 km/h. Then it gets noisy. It is very stable and has a good grip on the road up to about 180 km/h (I haven't tested it further) but it is very loud. Wind noise is generally OK, but the sunroof would whistle very loudly after 150 km/h. I don't know what caused it. It never leaked or something. This would make the passengers a bit nervous. As I like cruising at about 160-170 km/h, I finally started looking for something quieter and in the end I sold the car. I got myself a C200 Kompressor and it love it. You'd say - what were you expecting from a two liter naturally aspirated engine - and you'd be right. But the car offered enormous value for the money and it did a good job saving me expenses when I needed to commute a lot and drive longer distances.

I have answered that I wouldn't buy another Renault not because I am disappointed, I was rather pleasantly surprised by the brand. However, I like a rear wheel drive or an all wheel drive and I wouldn't compromise with this in the future. It just feels more natural. If this wasn't the concern, I'd happily buy a Laguna or a Nissan Leaf. I drove the latest Nissan Leaf from 2020 with 400 km reach on my job and it was quite nice. Renault seems to do a very good job finding a way to keep quality reasonably cheap. However, if you want no compromise, go for a Mercedes :)

Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? No

Review Date: 31st January, 2021

2nd Feb 2021, 12:22

Well written review. We have these in the UK as well. Generally Renault's from this time period are not known as reliable cars, but good to know a well maintained one can be worth keeping long term.

21st Feb 2021, 16:34

Thank you. I guess I've had luck with it.