1991 BMW 5 Series 525i 2.5L M50 gas

Summary:

Absolutely the best car for $1000

Faults:

Bought the car for a song about 2 months ago. I had the car checked by a BMW specialist and below is the list of what needs to be addressed:

Rear sub-frame suspension bushings need replacement. Front bushings on control arms need replacing. Struts will need replacement in the near future. Oil filter housing leaking (will be replaced soon). Slight fluid leak at the rear differential.

Nothing out of the ordinary for an almost 39 year old car.

General Comments:

I am a BMW enthusiast and also own an E36 325is coupe which I use as a weekend warrior in the Summer.

I bought the 525i because for my new job I have a 100 miles (ca. 161 km) commute (one way) and I wanted to have a comfortable ride. So far the car has behaved extremely well despite the issues reported above. Handling is terrific (I can't wait to see how it handles once all bushings have been done), the car picks up nicely (however it's not a Porsche) and keeps up very well on the highway with modern cars. It has a few little electronic gremlins, but I can live with that.

Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? Yes

Review Date: 23rd December, 2019

24th Dec 2019, 00:13

Actually it's only almost 29 years old, not 39. Still likely to be a money pit though, unfortunately... :{

25th Dec 2019, 12:55

A very brave choice. The reason they are so cheap is because they are money pits when older.

27th Dec 2019, 15:26

I fully agree. I have a 1987 M5 in red. It costs a fortune, worth it though.

27th Dec 2019, 23:22

I agree also, these are good cars. You can get them cheap, but you cannot keep them for years and years on the cheap. General reliability is good, even when compared to modern cars. Find a good independent garage and source parts online to keep costs down, and I would also not recommend anyone takes a car of this age to a dealer. The kid behind the counter would probably not know what they are, let alone provide you with parts!

1991 BMW 5 Series 525iA M50B25

Summary:

Fantastic automobile... but not for the weak of mind/spirit/wallet..

Faults:

To consider the abused state of my Bimmer when purchased... not too much (attesting to the reliability and forgiving nature BMW engineered into the E34).

First order of business: Tune-Up with Oil and Filters Change (Oil, Air and Cabin Air)

Rebuilt Front-End: Thrust Arms, Control Arms, Center Link, Tie-Rods, Sway-Bar Links, Idler Arm, Struts.

Rear Struts.

Intake Boot (between MAF and Throttle Body) : Cracked when purchased causing VERY rough idle.

Several Interior pieces.

Ground down rust and re-primed bottom of sunroof (and replaced seal.

Replaced Driver's door window motor.

...there are still MANY smaller repairs to perform...95% are cosmetic.

General Comments:

I originally bought this vehicle as a weekend project. I like Bimmers and I couldn't beat the price. That said, anyone purchasing a vehicle used (particularly one well out of warranty) should expect repairs. The older and higher mileage the vehicle the more expensive and numerous they are likely to be.

I've read many of the reviews here with pithy complaints about older cars and the repairs needed. A BMW is not just a vehicle; it is a commitment to quality, and as such when things go wrong it's likely to be more expensive a repair than your typical Toyota or Chevrolet. Likewise, it is also very likely to still be running strong when most cars are rusting to nothingness in a scrap-yard somewhere.

Overall, I can honestly say I'm impressed with my E34. It runs very well (especially at license losing speeds), it is the only vehicle I've owned which gets better mileage above 80mph than at 55. Handles very nimbly for a car weighing just shy of two tons loaded. Finally, with a few minor performance modifications (chip, headers, cams and ported-and-polished heads) it truly screams (think M5 style power) without too many compromises in economy and none in reliability.

Now, for the perspective owner of an E34. Owning a BMW is a commitment. It is a much more maintenance intensive car than a Honda. If you wish to have a reliable and safe vehicle, follow a few basic rules:

Use ONLY Full Synthetic Oils and Genuine BMW or Mann Filters every 6 months or 7500 miles.

Use BMW Coolants or Non-Water alternatives (such as Evans NPG+) with annual flush (except the Evans product every 5 years).

And, although you are driving a vehicle which gets relatively good mileage (considering size/weight/power) ; it is not a commuter car. You really need to get out an drive. Let it breathe. Floor it. It was built for the Autobahn (not rush-hour boredom). Drive it hard occasionally or you may end up with reliability issues as well.

Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? Yes

Review Date: 7th August, 2007