2000 Alfa Romeo 146 Reviews

2000 Alfa Romeo 146 1.6 Twin Spark 1.6 petrol from Malaysia

Model year2000
Year of manufacture2000
First year of ownership2004
Most recent year of ownership2005
Engine and transmission 1.6 petrol Manual
Performance marks 7 / 10
Reliability marks 2 / 10
Comfort marks 5 / 10
Running Costs (higher is cheaper) 1 / 10
Overall marks (average of all marks)
3.8 / 10
Distance when acquired138000 kilometres
Most recent distance146000 kilometres
Previous carMercedes-Benz S-Class

Summary:

I would've kept it if it was reliable

Faults:

Air Flow Sensor failed and replaced three times (!)

Faulty Intake Cam Variator.

Head gasket blown at 140,000km.

Shifter cup broke, could not select any gear. Had to have it towed home.

Clutch slave cylinder leaked in a middle of a traffic jam. Had to limp it home in second gear and turn off the engine every time I had to stop since there was no clutch disengagement.

Hatch creaked badly when raining. Never figured out what the problem was and just lived with it.

Electric fan failed in a middle of a traffic jam, causing overheating. Had it replaced with an aftermarket electric fan which was a lot cheaper.

Left rear wheel bearing failed.

General Comments:

Every time I looked back and think of all the problems this car had given me throughout my (brief) ownership, I just think some kind of curse was cast upon me. I mean, how could a car merely four years old could give me so much trouble? And the fact I sold my father's hand-me-down '84 Mercedes 280SE for this car made me think maybe I deserve such a curse for making such an inexcusable mistake.

Superstitions aside, I bought this car with the promise that it was a hoot to drive, and it was. Of course it was, it's an Alfa Romeo. The engine made the most intoxicating noise this side of a Ferrari, the shifter very slick, the looks are just drop dead gorgeous. The seats were contoured just right, and although I'm not a big fan of the Italian driving position, I learned to live with its quirk. The pedals are close together and made heel-and-toe shifting easy. What surprised me the most was the amount of interior room this car had, especially considering its compact size. I could easily carry five adults comfortably, and the boot will swallow quite a bit of luggage load.

Overall, I found it hard to fault its capabilities and practicalities. It really would've been a good car had it been (much) more reliable that it was. Because even with its enormous reliability problems, I still had some regret when I finally let go of it. I was truly disappointed with its problem. If it was even half as reliable as a Japanese or German brand, I would've kept it. When it did work, it put a smile on my face every time I drove it.

Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? No

Review Date: 3rd October, 2007

4th Jan 2008, 04:06

Hi, I'm the original poster of the Alfa 146. Yes, the cam variator made a diesel-like noise. At first, it was manageable, then it got worse and worse to the point where the cam position was stuck in the high rpm phase, so taking off from a stoplight, especially with the air-con on, was agonizing because it basically lost all power below 3000rpms.I finally gave in and replaced the variator which cost me about US$250.00.Its funny how you mentioned you're looking at a 156, because that was suppose to be my next car after the 146.I still think about the 156 every now and then because I just love Alfas when they work. Problem is, they often don't work.I've driven a Selespseed 156 2.0TS and my only complain is the jerkiness of the shift in auto mode around city. Other than that, it's a wonderful car. So there's my two cents in. If you have your heart set on the 156,get it at your own risk. I know that feeling, because Alfas have a way of seducing us car buffs.

24th Sep 2008, 06:10

I own a 145 1.6 TWIN SPARK and my variator has been knackered since I bought the car at 30,000 miles. I have just lived with the diesel rattle as it is only on start up. My main problem is rust on the floor pan due to inadequate under body sealing. Other than that the car has been fine besides having regularly to change the front wishbones due to bush wear, if not replaced in time can ruin your front tyres pretty quickly with wear on the inside edge. Also the support holding my windscreen washer bottle in the engine bay has rusted right through leaving the bottle slightly loose, anyone had a similar problem?

8th Mar 2010, 02:44

I have driven Alfas since 1979; Giulia, Alfetta, Alfasud, etc. They are wonderful to drive. Last year I bought a well-kept 146 1.6 TS for RM12k. The car is wonderful, but the 5th gear feels like a 4th, especially if you are driving below 120km/hr on the highway. Above it, it goes all the way to 195km/hr.

Bought it with a cam-variator spring loose (diesel sound on starting). So I changed the variator, timing belt kit as well as the tyres. It's 8 months and 17000 km now, and no problems. Only problem is you want to drive fast, a boy-racer not befitting my age.. haha.

13th Aug 2010, 06:50

I just bought a second hand Alfa 146. Your comments here really helpful. Will have mechanic look at the few areas mentioned and change if necessary. My previous car was a Peugeot 405SRi - literally bled my pocket numb. Hope this Alfa is better.

2000 Alfa Romeo 146 1.8 TS 1.8 from UK and Ireland

Year of manufacture2000
First year of ownership2002
Most recent year of ownership2002
Engine and transmission 1.8 Manual
Performance marks 10 / 10
Reliability marks 9 / 10
Comfort marks 9 / 10
Dealer Service marks 9 / 10
Running Costs (higher is cheaper) 9 / 10
Overall marks (average of all marks)
9.2 / 10
Distance when acquired95000 miles
Most recent distance99000 miles
Previous carFiat Bravo

Summary:

Great car. It's an Alfa!

Faults:

Absolutely nothing... other than:

Drivers window a little sticky when going back up.

General Comments:

Superb car. Very fast for a 1.8 of this size too! Handles well and can easily do 140 mph if you've got the road. Cabin is slightly boring and mundane, but oh that engine makes up for it. I am very very happy with my buy. 2000 V reg. Got it for 3400 pounds. Bargain. And it has a full Alfa SH. They looked better after T reg with the new colour coded panels and not the old plastic black bumpers.

Leaves most things for dust at traffic lights. Very smooth and easy to drive long distances and isn't a chore like it can be in other cars. Quite relaxing and its ready to liven up should you want it. Better than any ford or vauxhall. I have driven many cars including BMW's and Mercedes and this is up there with them without a shadow of a doubt. I love it.

Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? Yes

Review Date: 11th December, 2002

2nd Mar 2004, 04:52

I agree with all your comments, I AM ALSO happy for the 146 1.8 ts to remain alfas, and its owners best kept secret. And OOOOOOOOH BOY ------WHAT AN ENGINE.

Average review marks: 6.5 / 10, based on 2 reviews