1999 Volkswagen Beetle GLS TDI 1.9 turbo diesel from North America

Summary:

Fun, economical and pretty reliable

Faults:

The internal plastic clips of the window regulators often break, causing the glass to get stuck in the down position or jam.

Brake light switch failure; this leaves the car without tail lights and triggers warning lights.

A faulty coolant temperature sensor can cause the dashboard needle to read incorrectly or the computer to receive erroneous readings about the engine's condition (cold/hot).

The headlights accumulate water condensation, causing connection failures.

I only had a problem with the power window regulators once, which caused the glass to get stuck in the down position.

General Comments:

Contrary to what one might think, this is the most reliable and economical car I’ve ever owned, even better than the diesel Ford Tempo I had back in my college days in the 80s.

This is the second Volkswagen I’ve owned; the first was a Rabbit—also a good car, but it had more mechanical and corrosion issues, problems I didn't experience with my Beetle.

I have a lot of good things to say about the car.

First of all, it is incredibly economical; at least by American standards, it consumes very, very little fuel, making it more than ideal for daily use in both urban and rural settings.

The Volkswagen TDI engine, at least those from the late 20th century, like this one, is extremely reliable. It has a long service life and a simple design, making it very easy to repair when necessary. It is a bit noisy, but not excessively so, and only when starting up; otherwise, there is nothing out of the ordinary. Since it shares its mechanical and structural foundation with the Volkswagen Golf, it is relatively easy to find suspension, brake, and engine parts.

Easy to handle; it feels solid, substantial, and secure on the road, with good torque response at low RPMs. It brakes very well and offers excellent grip in corners—there is absolutely no swaying.

As for the design, it's a matter of taste. For many, it's not attractive and doesn't resemble the old Beetle; for me, it's the opposite. I find it very graceful, and sharing a platform with the Golf and Jetta makes it even more appealing.

The downsides of the car are the limited interior space and visibility; the rear seats and trunk are cramped due to the body's rounded shape, and the thick pillars hinder visibility.

If well-maintained, I think it remains an interesting option, even in today's climate; it’s not bad at all as a second car. It’s economical and doesn't give you major trouble.

Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? Yes

Review Date: 10th October, 2026

12th Oct 2026, 23:15

The TDI engine is the gold standard of this car, not just this one, but all Volkswagens from those years.

The issues with these Bugs are generally electronic or related to window regulators and plastic components; however, the engines were usually very reliable, even though the gasoline versions had high fuel consumption.

Nowadays, owning a New Beetle makes good sense, at least as a second car for city driving.

16th Oct 2026, 18:52

Certainly, if we compare it to a Ford Tempo from the 1980s, it is clear that the New Beetle is superior in terms of both performance and safety.

If we compare it to another VW from the same or a similar year (such as Golfs or Jettas from 1998, 1999, 2000, etc.), the Beetle consumed significantly more fuel, whether diesel or gasoline.

It was a nice, quite attractive car, even more popular in the U.S. than in Europe, but much of its initial success stemmed from the fact that it was, in theory (since it was essentially a Golf with a different design), the reincarnation of the classic Beetle.

In any case, it was a sound strategy by VW; in countries with large markets like the U.S. or the U.K., it was always going to find buyers, even if it wasn't a massive best-seller.

1999 Volkswagen Beetle GLS 2.0 gasoline (AQY) from Finland

Summary:

Fun and comfortable car for all driving, but can cost lot to maintain

Faults:

Power window switch broke.

Side view mirrors' heaters are not working.

Driver's seat heater is not working (to fix it would need new heating elements inside the seat).

The engine bay is cluttered, not much room to do maintenance. Requires patience. Permanently removing the plastic engine and battery covers makes 'em easier. And once you get hang of it, you'll know exactly where to put your hands.

The tires/rims are quite big -> getting decent quality tires will cost quite a lot. Especially northern Europe's winter/studded tires.

The trunk itself is awfully small, barely fitting your shopping bags. But if you don't have passengers on the back seat, you can flip the seat down and get wide space for even small furniture.

The car is heavy, so the stock rear disc brakes are little bit too small and heat up very easily in harder driving. It needs bigger, vented discs in my opinion.

Fuel efficiency is bad in these times of high gasoline costs.

General Comments:

The car is mechanically similar to the same year's Golf IV models, which are very popular, so the parts are easily available everywhere and are relatively cheap. But the New Beetle specific parts, like interior or body, they can cost a lot.

The seats are very comfortable, you have huge amount of head space -> fits perfectly for taller people. Also, very short people can also find surprisingly good seating positions, thanks to the wide adjustment possibilities.

The handling and performance is brilliant and sporty. If the car is in good condition, you feel like you're driving a bigger and more luxurious car than it really is.

Small but important thing: The windshield washer system is excellent - wide blades and high water pressure!

Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? Yes

Review Date: 24th June, 2014