2004 Jaguar X-Type Reviews - Page 3 of 4

2004 Jaguar X-Type 3.0 V6 from North America

Model year2004
Year of manufacture2004
First year of ownership2004
Most recent year of ownership2004
Engine and transmission 3.0 V6 Automatic
Performance marks 8 / 10
Comfort marks 10 / 10
Dealer Service marks 10 / 10
Running Costs (higher is cheaper) 8 / 10
Overall marks (average of all marks)
9.0 / 10
Distance when acquired0 miles
Most recent distance5000 miles
Previous carFord Taurus

Summary:

Take a pass on the BMW 300 Series for a REAL car

Faults:

A tiny piece of the body molding popped off of the roof (little tab).

There's a little rattle on the passenger side door. But it was easily fixed.

General Comments:

My wife and I researched cars quite a bit before buying this Jaguar. The general comments from the snobbish reviewers were disappointing. But we ignored them and gave it a test drive. The moment I was behind the wheel and on the road, my decision was made. Don't listen to the snobbish reviewers!

We bought this car fully loaded - luxury package, with both front seats heated, rear parking sensor, etc. Everything works as advertised.

The main point I want to make concerns the snobbish reviewers who keep comparing it to that itsy bitsy little BMW hatchback 300 series. Oh, its not a hatchback? Sorry, easy mistake to make. I see these 300 series cars on every corner. They are SO tiny! Where do these snobbish reviewers get off saying the Jaguar X-Type has a similar or same amount of room?! Crazy. Let's put it this way - you could easily fit a family of four in a Jaguar X-Type. In a 300 Series? Yeah, maybe, for like a 10 minute drive to the store, before the kids start pulling each other's hair out.

OK, size not an issue? Let's talk NHTSA crash test results. The X-Type comes with every airbag known to man. You got curtains, side doors, passenger side, etc. BMW? Don't think so. Jaguar X-Type scored 4 stars in every category. BMW? Nope. As a matter of fact, the 300 series had serious safety concerns noted for one of the categories. You going to trust your loved ones in that tiny danger box? Not me.

OK, let's talk price. Here's another one the snobbish reviewers get 100% completely wrong. Just pull up the stats on the web and see for yourself. I did it just a few minutes ago. I added up all the amenities we have on our fully-loaded Jaguar and guess what - the BMW is thousands, THOUSANDS more expensive! PLUS, it doesn't come with AWD!

Let's talk AWD. I've never had an AWD vehicle before. But, living in a mountain state, I figure it will come in handy. BMW? Not even an option from what I could see. The Jag has a death grip on the pavement. I am truly amazed at how the car feels with that immense grip. It's a truly comforting feel on those sleety days when you're on the freeway trying to pass a double-decker semi-trailer doing 75 mph. Let's face it, the truck driver probably won't even see your tiny BMW 300 series.

Sorry for the rant, but as you can tell, I am fed up with the reviewers. Its just like movies - most reviewers have their own little pet peeves and favorites and they aren't anything like us. The snobs point out the little plastic parts in the Jaguar cup holders, etc. Who cares? It holds the cup, right? It doesn't determine whether I have a good day or bad day, whether I swerve and end up in a ditch turned around 180 degrees, whether I can fit ALL of my parents' luggage in the trunk when we pick them up from the airport... They cry about how WONDERFUL the BMW 300 series handles compared to the Jaguar. Who are these people? Its like apples and oranges! AWD v. rear wheel drive? Tiny hatchback v. sedan? I'm no car expert, but these seem like some pretty BIG differences to me. If you read the reviews closely, you will see they all say the X-Type handles very well and the AWD is gripping (sorry for the pun).

In summary, forget the hype. Get a real car, not what everyone and their brother has. If you drive a BMW 300 series, I'm sorry you bought into the hype. Trade it in for an X-Type and start living life a little. Buy a Jaguar for its style, for its statement. It exudes success and refinement. What does the BMW 300 series exude? You're just like all the rest? The X-Type is perfect for 20-somethings or 30-somethings buying their first luxury car. Our next car will also be chosen from the same parking lot this one came from, just maybe a size or two bigger.

Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? Yes

Review Date: 8th December, 2004

29th Jan 2005, 15:55

I agree with the first comment. This guy is a snobbish reviewer for the X-Type, and totally against the 3-series, not "300 series," you illiterate person you. I happen to own a BMW 318i, but I don't go around saying that it is superior to all other entry-level luxury cars because I don't think that it is. From driving different brands, I can see that Mercedes, BMW, Jaguar, Volvo, Saab, and Audi design their cars differently to meet the different tastes and preferences of customers. My dad, granddad, and grandmother own Jaguars, one XJ6, one XK8 coupe, and one XK8 convertible, respectively. My granddad also owns a Mercedes-Benz. My mother used to own a Volvo, my sister had a Volkswagen, my uncle has a Land Rover, the list goes on.

So, I am a fan of ALL cars. I admire the X-Type and I hope to have one sitting next to my BMW one day. I also love every Mercedes, Volvo, and Audi that I've ever encountered. I think that they are all ingeniously designed cars that are worthy of consideration from EVERYONE. I wish that people would stop trying to make a competition out of which brand they own in a segment. Buy what you like for the simple reason that you prefer it and don't put down your neighbors for driving other brands that they prefer. In other words, drive your Jag, enjoy it, and wave politely to me when you see me on the road in my BMW, and I'll say: "that X-Type was tight."

2004 Jaguar X-Type Diesel 2.0 turbo diesel from UK and Ireland

Model year2004
Year of manufacture2004
First year of ownership2004
Most recent year of ownership2004
Engine and transmission 2.0 turbo diesel Manual
Performance marks 9 / 10
Reliability marks 10 / 10
Comfort marks 8 / 10
Dealer Service marks 6 / 10
Running Costs (higher is cheaper) 8 / 10
Overall marks (average of all marks)
8.2 / 10
Distance when acquired0 miles
Most recent distance14000 miles
Previous carBMW 3 Series

Summary:

Very good, very economic, great fun to drive

Faults:

Squeak from handbrake cable - fixed at dealers in first month.

General Comments:

This car is the SE version with folding mirrors, reversing aid, met paint and sat navigation (this is one thing that as a business driver I will never want to be without having had it, fantastic system, but £2,000 extra!)

Genuine 50+ mpg on a run, very economical and very quick!

Can't think of anything wrong with this car. Quick and economical with a good image, what more is there?

My car is gold with cream leather, must be the best colour way, have a look at it yourself!

Would you buy another car from this manufacturer? Yes

Review Date: 7th December, 2004

24th Apr 2005, 10:32

Sounds very nice!but where is the pic?

11th Sep 2005, 04:24

I have the exact same car, colour, spec etc and when its good its very very good and when its bad, the dealer at Cardiff is hopless. Can't get jobs resolved, have to wait a month to get the car into the workshops. I will go back to a BMW just because I can't stand the hassle of Jaguar ownership.

That's from a bloke whos second car was an XK120 (long ago) e type, loads of MK2s etc this was my first new Jag (number 11!) what a shame!

31st Jan 2009, 14:41

I have now owned a 2 litre diesel SE for 3 years. The car is fantastic, never letting me down.

Yes, some of the comments are correct, the dealers could provide a better service.

There is a common fault with these cars, rust under the chrome boot strip, above the rear number plate. Therefore, when purchasing a second hand car check for this.

The cars are well designed, standing out in the crowd and very cheap to run. My brother bought a Sports Premium after driving my SE. Both he and I are so pleased with the cars that we will buy another Jaguar in a year or so.

PS my other car is a Mercedes C220 so I feel I can compare like with like.

Average review marks: 7.6 / 10, based on 15 reviews